Consolidation and the law of big numbers
The credit crisis may have slowed activity, but mergers continue apace. NewsCorp took Dow Jones, Google took DoubleClick, Microsoft snapped up aQuantive, Yahoo! took Right Media, Microsoft took Yahoo!, Pfizer took Wyeth, Merck took Schering-Plough, InBev took Anheuser-Busch, Vodafone went for Hutchison Essar, Danone took Royal Numico, Bank of America took Merrill Lynch, Carphone Warehouse linked with Best Buy, Thomson Corp merged with Reuters, Kraft ate Cadbury.
- Source: Thomson Financial as of March 2011
Consolidation among media owners also continues unabated. NewsCorp takes and disposes of DirecTV and bids for BSkyB, Comcast tried to take Disney and takes NBC. Legislation has favoured more consolidation in the US and the UK, although recent events and changes in administrations may alter that. Even in Brazil, which has been fiercely protectionist, you can buy 30% of Globo or Editora Abril. And in Australia, recently introduced legislation relaxing media ownership rules triggered a media asset bidding frenzy. Germany allows foreign ownership of TV; Italy concentrates further through the Gasparri Bill. In Spain, the government allows a 25% share of the free-to-air market and the Polanco family sells a television stake to Berlusconi’s Mediaset, and Antenna 3 and La Sexta have had on-and-off merger discussions. Clients and media owners are not alone: retail consolidates, too. Morrison takes Safeway; Boots and Alliance merge and go private shortly thereafter. In Latin America, Walmart enters the north east of Brazil by acquiring part of Ahold’s interests, Lider consumes Carrefour’s Chilean interests, and Jumbo buys Disco in Argentina. Rumours surround Walmart and Carrefour and Home Depot and Kingfisher.
In line with the laws of big numbers, the challenge to Walmart, Tesco and Home Depot will be how they can successfully manage expansion outside their home markets. Tesco already has over half its square footage outside Britain (but much less of its profits) and has sent its UK managing director to the West Coast to manage its US expansion as Fresh & Easy. It will not be simple; the demands are different and the model will be significantly based on rehabilitating blighted areas on the West Coast. Early signs are mixed.
It is no surprise that agencies are also consolidating. Havas and Aegis, IPG and Publicis, Dentsu selling its 15% stake in Publicis in 2012 to buy a global network of its own (effectively a rolling $1.2 billion equity put on Publicis by Dentsu), Ipsos, GfK and Nielsen being involved in significant consolidation activity in market research are all current rumours. Certainly in the one area where there are big economies of scale – media buying – consolidation is significant. To negotiate with a Rupert Murdoch, Sumner Redstone, Mel Karmazin, Bob Iger or Brian Roberts, larger scale is essential. Media buying, or what we call Media Investment Management, is one of WPP’s fastest-growing businesses, driven by clients looking for media-buying efficiencies – rather than reductions in agencies’ commissions. Like-for-like revenue growth in the last four years has consistently been well above WPP’s overall like-for-like growth. Often client savings on gross media budgets of 5-10% are achievable.
Media savings are driving client centralisations and are a quick kill in demonstrating efficiencies, as Nestlé and Unilever have shown. The traditional media owners are not only having to fend off disintermediation by new technologies, but the pricing pressure from significant consolidation of media budgets. But even on the creative side, voracious procurement departments and ill-judged price competition by agencies themselves are driving consolidation (the $100 million pitch win headline in Advertising Age or Campaign is more satisfying than real revenue). We have seen two of our competitors desperately write cheques or subsidise account pitches to the tune of $20 to $30 million to retain accounts globally or in the UK – one of which decisions has been reversed in 18 months in our favour. Competitors seem to ignore the exponential risks of going short in markets that may be becoming increasing long, by giving undeliverable media pricing guarantees and failing to book consequent balance sheet liabilities.